archiving of SOWACS
proudly sponsored by


this could be
your logo - >
 

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Neutron Probes Time Schedule/Alternative Methods



Clem Wehner writes

Some idea of when the use of Neutron Probes will be 
banned may appear in reports from the recent 
World Congress of Soil Science in Montpellier, France,
20 to 26 August.

It isn't so much the concern about prolonged human
exposure to fast neutrons that is causing a decrease
in use of the neutron probe technique for measuring
soil moisture. Other factors are:

1)  Neutron probe equipment is more expensive
    to buy, operate and maintain than newer,
    alternative systems for measuring moisture
    in soils and other media.

2)  Calibration is required for each kind of 
    soil studied with neutron probes.

3)  Neutron probe operators and equipment,
    including transport, have to be licensed.

An alternative method for measuring soil moisture, 
and one of the easiest to use with satisfactory
accuracy is a TDR system such as the one offered
by ESI Environmental Sensors Inc.

        http://www.esica.com

My opinion is biased by a Market Assessment of 
Reasearch and Technology survey (1992)I did that
preceeded final development of the TDR system
before it was commercialized by ESI (1994).

Clem Wehner     C. Wehner & Associates
                Marketing Consultants International
                Victoria, BC, Canada V9A 3K2
                Ph/Fx: 250-383-1959
                E-Mail: cww@pacificcoast.net

        -------------  0  ------------   
Posted on Sowacs were:

> Could anyone clarify for me any specific legislation
  current or pending
> which will ban the use of Neutron Probes in the future.
>
> Alternatively if people consider a ban is likely when
 do people think it is likely to occur?
>
>
        -----------------  0  -----------

I think they might wait until there's an alternative....
as I'm developing an instrument which could be the
alternative, I would be interested in a time scedule too ;-)

best regards
R. Maag              mailto:romaag@meteolabor.ch
------------------------------------------------------------------
     visit our homepage at http://www.meteolabor.ch/e/lumbric.htm
------------------------------------------------------------------